The 2018 Circle City Conference All-Conference Football Team as selected by the member coaches:

 

Mark Nondorf – Bishop Chatard
Jay Higgins – Brebeuf Jesuit
Daylen Taylor – Bishop Chatard
Dylan Crossan – Guerin Catholic
Brandon Berger – Roncalli
John Harris – Roncalli
David Whittemore – Bishop Chatard
Gabe Wright – Brebeuf Jesuit
Caleb Ellison – Brebeuf Jesuit
Simon Banks – Brebeuf Jesuit
Elijah Mahan – Roncalli
Joseph Solomon – Bishop Chatard
Isaiah Martin – Brebeuf Jesuit
Tyler Miller – Brebeuf Jesuit
Eric Osborn – Bishop Chatard
Wyatt Schrader – Bishop Chatard
Hank Bates – Guerin Catholic
Will Poynter – Guerin Catholic
Charles Bock – Guerin Catholic
Jack Wardzala – Roncalli
Adam Vander Kooy – Brebeuf Jesuit
Pat Mastrian – Bishop Chatard
Billy Freudenthal – Guerin Catholic
Will Meyer – Bishop Chatard
Andrew Sowinski – Bishop Chatard

Special Teams
Alec Bevelhimer – Brebeuf Jesuit (two-sport All-Conference)
Ben Schrage – Bishop Chatard